ERA Ranking Review Document

Getting the spreadsheet

From the USyd intranet

Download is available on the USyd Intranet.

Opening this link http://www.usyd.edu.au/research/docs/ERA_Research_Journal_Ranking_Workbook.xls will allow you to open or save the Excel Spreadsheet. We recommend that unless you save files to a network drive in a structured manner that you save it straight to your desktop.

We recommend that you keep the default name “ERA Research Journal Ranking Workbook.xls”

Open

Open “ERA_Research_Journal_Ranking_Workbook.xls” from where you have just saved it.

From the ARC site

If you do not have intranet access, you will need to download the zip file from the ARC site.

Download and unzip the spreadsheet

http://www.arc.gov.au/zip/era_journal_Ranking.zip

Open the above link, and if you get a security warning, click “Ok”

Unzipping the spreadsheet

You will be prompted to either download or open the file

Select "Open"

A new window will open with one file listed (“ERA Research Journal Ranking Workbook”)

From Folder Tasks, select Extract all files, in the Wizard window select “Browse”, then in the “Select a destination” window highlight “Desktop” and then click the “OK” button

download from ARC

The “Select a destination” window will disappear, and click the “Next” button.

When finished, a new window should open displaying all your desktop files.

The instructions resume from [[b||Open]].


Opening the Spreadsheet

Macro Security Warning #1

Macro Security Warning #1

If the following screen does NOT appear, click here for “Macro Security Warning #2”

Macro Security Warning 1#

This warning means that you need to change your security settings within Excel.

Click “OK”

At this point the spreadsheet will not work until you update your security settings, and reopen the spreadsheet

From the menu along the top of the spreadsheet select Tools / Macro / Security

Setting Macro Security to medium

From there, select the option "Medium"

Click "OK"

For this change to take effect you will need to close and reopen the spreadsheet. You do not have to save it at this point.

Macro Security Warning #2

If you get this security warning

Macro Security Warning #2

Select “Enable Macros”. This will come up each time you open the spreadsheet, and you must enable macros each time you open it.


Conducting the Review

Your demographics

Please input your details on the “Rankings” Tab

reviewer details

NB – Institution has a Pulldown list of Institution names, but to make things easier while compiling the full list for Sydney please include your department per the example.

Each record that you add, modify, or delete from the list will have this contact information on it to allow the ARC to contact if there is contention about a particular Journal ranking.

Filtering journals to review

  • The “4-digit FoR Filter” allows multiple selections at once:
    • Click “4-Digit FoR Filter” button
    • Scroll down to the 1st selection
    • Click the “Up Arrow” ↑ button above the selection list and ensure that it appears in the selection box above
    • Repeat the process till all required FoRs are input
    • NB – the default “Show Alternate FoRs” means that if the journal is in your requested FoR list it will show up with every FoR that has been assigned to it
    • Click the “Filter” button
  • Filtering by 2-digit FoR only allows for one selection
  • Once filtered you can sort by Journal Name or by Ranking

You can’t filter by name, but by selecting “Clear Filters” and then “Sort by Journal Name” your can either scroll down until you find that journal name, or use the “Find” function within excel which is

Indicating agreement and / or amendments

First, select the Journal you wish to action by clicking on its name from the list

This will bring up the following screen:

Journal review screen

There are 4 actions that can be made for each existent Journal / FoR combination:

  • Indicate agreement with all aspects of the journal’s rankings for that FoR
  • Amend the ranking against an FoR
  • Delete the journal for a specific FoR
  • Add a new FoR and Ranking to the Journal

Note; if you wish to do multiples of the above actions, complete each change and save the record first. Eg – if you want to up or downgrade a Journal’s ranking against on an existing FoR AND assign a new FoR to the Journal, edit the existing record and save, THEN re-select the record and associate the new FoR

A yellow background indicates that this is a mandatory field to be completed for a given change.

NB - Clicking “Save” only saves the requested record update requested back to spreadsheet; it doesn’t save the spreadsheet itself

It is highly recommended that you save your spreadsheet frequently

Please do NOT use the “In Agreement” function on the “Rankings” sheet UNLESS you are in agreement with the rankings of all Journal and FoR combination that you have not made an amendment to.

What you CAN’T do with this spreadsheet is to add a new Journal. If you believe that there is a journal missing from the list, please send the details of that journal and the FOR that you would associate with it to the appropriate FOR Coordinator.

Viewing modifications / recommendations you are submitting

  • Click the “Modifications Report” button in cell D5
    • Only records that you have edited (and “saved”) are displayed
    • The Yellow cells indicate the changes you have submitted

Submitting the Changes

Once you have completed your review you will need to send the changes to the appropriate FOR 2 digit co-ordinator from the list below.

To do this, you will need to copy the modifications into a new spreadsheet, save it, and then email it.

Copy the modifications

  • Save the spreadsheet
  • click the Modifications Report button – Do NOT just click to the Modifications_Report tab as this is only as recent as the last time you clicked the Modifications Report button
  • Hi-light the entire sheet by selecting the area that is at the Column A and Row1 intersection
  • When the whole sheet is highlighted
    • Simultaneously push the and buttons (to Copy), then
    • Simultaneously push the and buttons (to create a new worksheet), then
    • Simultaneously push the and buttons (to paste into the new spreadsheet

Save the new file

  • In the same directory or location as the original file
  • Save it as “ERA-Rev-dept-surname” (eg ERA-Rev-Maths-Smith)

Then please email it to the appropriate Two-digit FOR Co-ordinator



FOR Co-ordinators

FoR Division

FoR Division Title

Coordinator

Email

 01

Mathematical Sciences

 

Nalini Joshi

cc: Norm Dancer

 

n.joshi@usyd.edu.au

cc: normd@maths.usyd.edu.au

 02

Physical Sciences

Ben Eggleton

 

egg@physics.usyd.edu.au

 03

Chemical Sciences

 

Cameron Kepert

 

c.kepert@chem.usyd.edu.au

 04

Earth Sciences

 

Adriana Dutkiewicz

a.dutkiewicz@usyd.edu.au

 05

Environmental Sciences

 

Gavin Birch

 

gavin@geosci.usyd.edu.au

 06

Biological Sciences

 

Steve Simpson

 

via Pedro Teixeira:

pedro@bio.usyd.edu.au

 07

Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences

Alex McBratney

A.Mcbratney@usyd.edu.au

 08

Information and Computing Sciences

Albert Zomaya 

cc: Dr Masa Takatsuka

a.zomaya@usyd.edu.au

cc: masa@it.usyd.edu.au

 09

Engineering

 

Assaad Masri

cc: Dr X Liao

 

a.masri@usyd.edu.au

cc: X.Liao@usyd.edu.au

 10

Technology

 

David McKenzie

D.McKenzie@physics.usyd.edu.au

 11

Medical and Health Sciences

David Cook and Kathy Refshauge

davidc@physiol.usyd.edu.au

K.Refshauge@usyd.edu.au

 

 12

Built Environment and Design

Andy Dong

a.dong@arch.usyd.edu.au

 13

Education

 

Patrick Brownlee

cc: Janette Bobis

p.brownlee@edfac.usyd.edu.au

cc: j.bobis@edfac.usyd.edu.au

 14

Economics

 

Tony Aspromourgos

 

t.aspromourgos@econ.usyd.edu.au

 15

Commerce, Management, Tourism and Services

Greg Patmore

g.patmore@econ.usyd.edu.au

 16

Studies in Human Society

 

Graeme Gill

g.gill@usyd.edu.au

 17

Psychology and Cognitive Sciences

Sally Andrews

 

sallya@psych.usyd.edu.au

 18

Law and Legal Studies

 

Terry Carney

T.Carney@usyd.edu.au

 19

Studies in Creative Arts and Writing

Colin Rhodes

c.rhodes@usyd.edu.au

 20

Language, Communication and Culture

Margaret Rogerson

margaret.rogerson@arts.usyd.edu.au

 21

History and Archaeology

 

Andrew Fitzmaurice

andrew.fitzmaurice@usyd.edu.au

 

 22

Philosophy and Religious Studies

Duncan Ivison

 

duncan.ivison@usyd.edu.au


FOR Divisions and Groups

Index

FOR Divisions and Groups

01 - Mathematical Sciences

12 - Built Environment And Design

02 - Physical Sciences

13 - Education

03 - Chemical Sciences

14 - Economics

04 - Earth Sciences

15 - Commerce , Management , Tourism And Services

05 - Environmental Sciences

16 - Studies In Human Society

06 - Biological Sciences

17 - Psychology And Cognitive Sciences

07 - Agricultural And Veterinary Sciences

18 - Law And Legal Studies

08 - Information And Computing Sciences

19 - Studies In Creative Arts And Writing

09 - Engineering

20 - Language, Communication And Culture

10 - Technology

21 - History And Archaeology

11 - Medical And Health Sciences

22 - Philosophy And Religious Studies

01 MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES

0101

Pure Mathematics

0102

Applied Mathematics

0103

Numerical and Computational Mathematics

0104

Statistics

0105

Mathematical Physics

0199

Other Mathematical Sciences

02 PHYSICAL SCIENCES

0201

Astronomical and Space Sciences

0202

Atomic, Molecular, Nuclear, Particle and Plasma Physics

0203

Classical Physics

0204

Condensed Matter Physics

0205

Optical Physics

0206

Quantum Physics

0299

Other Physical Sciences

03 CHEMICAL SCIENCES

0301

Analytical Chemistry

0302

Inorganic Chemistry

0303

Macromolecular and Materials Chemistry

0304

Medicinal and Biomolecular Chemistry

0305

Organic Chemistry

0306

Physical Chemistry (incl. Structural)

0307

Theoretical and Computational Chemistry

0399

Other Chemical Sciences

04 EARTH SCIENCES

0401

Atmospheric Sciences

0402

Geochemistry

0403

Geology

0404

Geophysics

0405

Oceanography

0406

Physical Geography and Environmental Geoscience

0499

Other Earth Sciences

05 ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES

0501

Ecological Applications

0502

Environmental Science and Management

0503

Soil Sciences

0599

Other Environmental Sciences

06 BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES

0601

Biochemistry and Cell Biology

0602

Ecology

0603

Evolutionary Biology

0604

Genetics

0605

Microbiology

0606

Physiology

0607

Plant Biology

0608

Zoology

0699

Other Biological Sciences

07 AGRICULTURAL AND VETERINARY SCIENCES

0701

Agriculture, Land and Farm Management

0702

Animal Production

0703

Crop and Pasture Production

0704

Fisheries Sciences

0705

Forestry Sciences

0706

Horticultural Production

0707

Veterinary Sciences

0799

Other Agricultural and Veterinary Sciences

08 INFORMATION AND COMPUTING SCIENCES

0801

Artificial Intelligence and Image Processing

0802

Computation Theory and Mathematics

0803

Computer Software

0804

Data Format

0805

Distributed Computing

0806

Information Systems

0807

Library and Information Studies

0899

Other Information and Computing Science

09 ENGINEERING

0901

Aerospace Engineering

0902

Automotive Engineering

0903

Biomedical Engineering

0904

Chemical Engineering

0905

Civil Engineering

0906

Electrical and Electronic Engineering

0907

Environmental Engineering

0908

Food Sciences

0909

Geomatic Engineering

0910

Manufacturing Engineering

0911

Maritime Engineering

0912

Materials Engineering

0913

Mechanical Engineering

0914

Resources Engineering and Extractive Metallurgy

0915

Interdisciplinary Engineering

0999

Other Engineering

10 TECHNOLOGY

1001

Agricultural Biotechnology

1002

Environmental Biotechnology

1003

Industrial Biotechnology

1004

Medical Biotechnology

1005

Communications Technologies

1006

Computer Hardware

1007

Nanotechnology

1099

Other Technology

11 MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES

1101

Medical Biochemistry and Metabolomics

1102

Cardiovascular Medicine and Haematology

1103

Clinical Sciences

1104

Complementary and Alternative Medicine

1105

Dentistry

1106

Human Movement and Sports Science

1107

Immunology

1108

Medical Microbiology

1109

Neurosciences

1110

Nursing

1111

Nutrition and Dietetics

1112

Oncology and Carcinogenesis

1113

Ophthalmology and Optometry

1114

Paediatrics and Reproductive Medicine

1115

Pharmacology and Pharmaceutical Sciences

1116

Medical Physiology

1117

Public Health and Health Services

1199

Other Medical and Health Sciences

12 BUILT ENVIRONMENT AND DESIGN

1201

Architecture

1202

Building

1203

Design Practice and Management

1204

Engineering Design

1205

Urban and Regional Planning

1299

Other Built Environment and Design

13 EDUCATION

1301

Education Systems

1302

Curriculum and Pedagogy

1303

Specialist Studies in Education

1399

Other Education

14 ECONOMICS

1401

Economic Theory

1402

Applied Economics

1403

Econometrics

1499

Other Economics

15 COMMERCE , MANAGEMENT , TOURISM AND SERVICES

1501

Accounting, Auditing and Accountability

1502

Banking, Finance and Investment

1503

Business and Management

1504

Commercial Services

1505

Marketing

1506

Tourism

1507

Transportation and Freight Services

1599

Other Commerce, Management, Tourism and Services

16 STUDIES IN HUMAN SOCIETY

1601

Anthropology

1602

Criminology

1603

Demography

1604

Human Geography

1605

Policy and Administration

1606

Political Science

1607

Social Work

1608

Sociology

1699

Other Studies in Human Society

17 PSYCHOLOGY AND COGNITIVE SCIENCES

1701

Psychology

1702

Cognitive Sciences

1799

Other Psychology and Cognitive Sciences

18 LAW AND LEGAL STUDIES

1801

Law

1802

Maori Law

1899

Other Law and Legal Studies

19 STUDIES IN CREATIVE ARTS AND WRITING

1901

Art Theory and Criticism

1902

Film, Television and Digital Media

1903

Journalism and Professional Writing

1904

Performing Arts and Creative Writing

1905

Visual Arts and Crafts

1999

Other Studies in Creative Arts and Writing

20 LANGUAGE, COMMUNICATION AND CULTURE

2001

Communication and Media Studies

2002

Cultural Studies

2003

Language Studies

2004

Linguistics

2005

Literary Studies

2099

Other Language, Literature and Culture

21 HISTORY AND ARCHAEOLOGY

2101

Archaeology

2102

Curatorial and Related Studies

2103

Historical Studies

2199

Other History and Archaeology

22 PHILOSOPHY AND RELIGIOUS STUDIES

2201

Applied Ethics

2202

History and Philosophy of Specific Fields

2203

Philosophy

2204

Religion and Religious Studies

2299

Other Philosophy and Religious Studies