The Federal Government’s proposed Digital Detox initiative has reignited debate about the role of technology in Australian classrooms. University of Sydney experts welcome efforts to ensure technology supports learning, but caution against one-size-fits-all restrictions that overlook differences in learning needs, accessibility and equity.
Not all screen time is equal
Associate Professor of English Education Jen Scott Curwood, Director of the Sydney Games and Play Lab, co-founder and Chief Learning Officer of digital game platform Ludolio, and core member of the Centre for Artificial Intelligence, Trust, and Governance, says the debate should move beyond simple measures of screen time and focus on educational outcomes.
“The Digital Detox report is right to ask education systems, schools, and teachers to make more deliberate, better-informed decisions about technology in the classroom. But a digital detox treats all screen time as the same, and it isn't,” she said.
“An hour spent passively scrolling is very different from an hour spent designing a game, critiquing an AI output, or collaborating on a digital story. The question isn't how much technology students use; it's what they're doing with it, and how it can support improved learning outcomes.”
Any national restrictions must consider the equity of technology across Australia, Associate Professor Curwood warns.
“What's missing from the report is the digital divide. For hundreds of thousands of Australian families, school is where children get reliable, meaningful access to technology. A digital detox might be easy for a family with laptops, tablets, and fast internet at home. For students without that access, it risks widening the very inequities our schools are meant to close. Any national limits on screen use must be designed with equity front and centre.”
Drawing on her own research, Associate Professor Scott Curwood says digital technologies can support learning when used intentionally.
“In my research in schools, I have seen students analyse narratives, ethics, and systems through carefully chosen digital games, and the depth of thinking is remarkable.
“Separately, generative AI raises its own challenges. Students need to learn how AI tools work, where they fail, and how to question what they produce. That’s critical media literacy, and it can’t be built if technology is pushed out of the classroom.”
Earlier this year, the University of Sydney launched Ludolio, a world-first digital gaming platform allowing school and university libraries to lend video games to students for learning and research. Photo credit: University of Sydney
50
automatic
LinkTechnology to support learning
Dr Catherine Smyth, Program Director of the Bachelor of Education (Primary) says teachers share many of the concerns raised in the Digital Detox paper, particularly when technology detracts from learning, yet measuring screen time alone risks overlooking other considerations such as accessibility.
“Screens that distract students, or AI that does the thinking for them, have no place in a primary classroom,” she said.
“I agree that technology should only be used when it has a clear purpose for learning. My concern is that blanket time limits measure the wrong thing. A student using text-to-speech to access a reading task, or a child with disability using assistive technology to show what they know, is not “screen time” in the same way as passive scrolling.
“Schools have legal obligations to make reasonable adjustments for students with disability, and many of those adjustments are digital. Any national guidance needs to protect them.”
Dr Smyth says schools should be guiding students to navigate new technologies responsibly, and teachers are best placed to determine when technology adds value in a classroom.
“Australian students need to learn how to use AI critically and ethically. If primary schools don’t teach those skills, children will learn them by default at home, without guidance.
“The new Digital Detox Taskforce should listen closely to teachers and initial teacher education providers, and back teachers’ professional judgement about when technology adds value and when it doesn’t. We are preparing the next generation of primary teachers to make exactly those calls.”
Professor Jim Tognolini, Director of the Educational Measurement and Assessment Hub at the University of Sydney, said schools need to balance legitimate concerns about technology with ensuring students develop the digital capabilities they will need in the future.
“There is a real risk that in our efforts to address concerns about technology, we end up depriving young people of the skills they need to navigate a digital world,” he said.
“Technology is now embedded in almost every aspect of education, work and daily life, so schools have a responsibility to help students learn how to use these tools critically and effectively.
“Instead of regulating every possible risk, we should be empowering teachers to exercise professional judgement in the classroom. Educators are best placed to determine when technology supports learning and when it becomes a distraction. Too often, public debate about technology is driven by fear and political rhetoric, leading to restrictions that may feel decisive but do little to address the underlying issues.”
The Digital Detox Taskforce should listen closely to teachers and initial teacher education providers, and back teachers’ professional judgement about when technology adds value and when it doesn’t.
Dr Catherine Smyth
Program Director for the B.Ed. (Primary) degree at the Sydney School of Education and Social Work
Policy guided by evidence
Economist Associate Professor Marian Vidal-Fernandez argues education policy must keep pace with emerging evidence.
“Instead of a one-off taskforce, decisions about screen use in classrooms should be based on solid causal evidence about how children learn at different ages and reviewed continuously by a permanent advisory panel of experts, teachers, parents and secondary students,” she said.
“We also need to think about different uses of screens at different stages of development. Screens are now part of our everyday life and encompass interactive technologies such as iPads and phones, non-interactive media such as television documentaries, and hybrid formats such as computers. Some are more useful than others depending on a child’s age and learning needs.”
Major curriculum changes need to be matched with appropriate resources and support, and take equity into account, Associate Professor Vidal-Fernandez says.
“Curriculum changes need adequate resourcing if they are to be implemented effectively. Too often, schools are expected to absorb major curriculum reforms without the support or resources needed to deliver them.
“The proposed changes also assume there is screen access to limit. Yet recent research reveals three in four First Nations people in remote communities are digitally excluded. Those missing from the screen-time conversation are often the same people overlooked in our curriculum.”
Digital technologies can support classroom learning when used intentionally, experts say. Photo credit: Paul Miller/AAP
50
automatic
LinkWhat the research says
Dr Ben Zunica in the Sydney School of Education and Social Work was a coauthor for the Best Practice in Screen Use for Education research project, funded by the NSW Government.
He says the research highlights the complexity of screen use in schools.
“Our research into screen use in NSW schools has provided important evidence about how digital technologies are being used in classrooms and the circumstances in which they support student learning. The two published reports draw on extensive surveys with students, teachers, school leaders and parents, alongside observations of 68 classes across numerous locations in NSW.
“For me, the value of this research lies in the nuanced discussion of how screens are currently used in schools, outlining both positive and negative perspectives. It provides evidence that can help teachers, schools and policymakers make more informed decisions about when and how technology should be used to engage learners and improve school teaching.”
Hero photo: Adobe Stock
Media contact
Manual Name : Liv Clayworth
Manual Description :
Manual Address :
Manual Addition Info Title :
Manual Addition Info Content :
Profile image :
Manual Type : contact
_self
Auto Type : contact
Auto Addition Title :
Auto Addition Content :
Auto Name : true
Auto Position : true
Auto Profile image :
Auto Phone Number : false
Auto Mobile Number : true
Auto Email Address : true
Auto Address : false
UUID :